ProWritingAid
-
ProWritingAid (ProWritingAid Ltd, UK, 2013, Active, Not Shut Down)
Status: Active (founded 2013 by Chris Banks; 4M+ users; 2026-01 pricing restructure Premium 120/yr, new Premium Pro $144/yr; prowritingaid.com + desktop + all extensions live 2026-09). Category
ai-productivity-data;pipeline_stage=none. Not a generative AI writer (→ Jasper/ChatGPT), not a lightweight grammar popper (→ Grammarly) — it is the report-stack editing coach: 25+ craft reports (pacing/sticky sentences/dialogue tags/overused words/sensory language) over grammar, built for manuscript-length revision inside Scrivener/Word/Docs, not inline Slack fixes.1. Introduction
ProWritingAid is “Grammarly for people who actually want to learn to write.” Beyond correctness it runs 25+ analytical reports on style, structure, readability, repetition, sentence-length variation, clichés, diction, consistency, and fiction-specific signals (dialogue tags, pacing, POV drift), each with an explainer so the writer improves rather than just accepts a redline. 2024–26 it added AI layers — Rephrases (tone/distance rewrites), Sparks (expand/summarize/continue), Chapter Critique (developmental AI feedback per chapter), Manuscript Analysis / Virtual Beta Reader (Story Credits, metered), and document-type goals (fiction/academic/business). It edits where you write: MS Word, Google Docs, Scrivener (native, the killer integration), Outlook, Chrome/Firefox/Safari/Edge, macOS/Win desktop. Plagiarism is not in base Premium — it’s a separate credit pack (or bundled 50/yr in old “Premium+” / metered in Premium Pro). English only (US/UK/AU/CA variants).
2. Core Features
Layer Capability Notes 25+ reports Grammar, style, overused words, sticky sentences, sentence variety, passive, clichés, dialogue tags, pacing, readability, consistency, homonyms, alliteration Depth no grammar-only tool matches AI rewrite Rephrases (formal/informal/longer/shorter/fluent/sensory), Sparks (expand/summarize/continue), 3–50/day by tier Not a draft generator, edit-side only Fiction/dev edit Chapter Critique 1–3/day, Manuscript Analysis, Virtual Beta Reader, Plot/Marketability (Story Credits metered) Story Credits ~$25+ each full-MS run Integrations Word, Google Docs, Scrivener (native win/mac), Outlook, Chrome/Firefox/Safari/Edge, desktop macOS/Win No mobile app, no EU region Style control Custom style guide, terminology base, document-type goals, ignore-rules per context, author-comparison (90 fiction authors) Power-user knobs Plagiarism Separate credit pack (40/100) or 50/yr in old Premium+; not in 2026 Premium Common complaint No No non-English, no autonomous agent, no real-time-as-fast-as-Grammarly on 10k+ words, no human editor replacement Slowdowns on long docs 3. Pricing (2026-08, USD)
Tier Monthly Annual eff/mo Lifetime Limits Free $0 $0 — 500 words/check, 2 report runs/day, 10 Rephrases/day, 3 Sparks/day, 19 core reports, web only Premium $30 **120/yr) $399 Unlimited words/reports, 25+ reports, 5 Sparks/day, 1 Chapter Critique/day, custom style guide, integrations, 40% off Story Credits Premium Pro $36 **144/yr) $699 50 Sparks/day, 3 Chapter Critiques/day, live author workshops, 65% off Story Credits, priority support Teams $9–12/seat/mo (annual, min 2–3 seats) — — Shared style guide, admin, analytics Enterprise Custom Custom — SSO, DPA, central billing Add-ons Plagiarism 40/100; Story Credits à la carte — — — pricing_type=freemium-per-seat-subscription+lifetime+metered-addons;starting_price=$0; 2026-01 Premium annual +52% (120); monthly is 3× annual (120); 3-day refund window on annual/lifetime, monthly non-refundable — Trustpilot gripes cluster here.4. Access Type
🌐 prowritingaid.com web · macOS/Win desktop · Word/Outlook add-in · Google Docs add-on · Scrivener plugin (native) · Chrome/Firefox/Safari/Edge extensions · no mobile app, no MCP, no API for self-serve.
5. Reviews (2026)
- Aggregate ~4.6/5 (G2 4.5/5 ~48, Capterra 4.7/5 ~497, Trustpilot 4.4/5 ~549, GetApp/SoftwareAdvice 4.7).
- Praise: report depth unmatched for fiction/long-form, Scrivener integration best-in-class, lifetime $399 pays back ~40 months, teaches craft not just corrects, explains every flag.
- Complaints: dense UI overwhelms casual users, slower than Grammarly on 10k+ words, English-only, plagiarism not in Premium, 3-day refund stingy, Rephrases can trip AI-detection in academic contexts, false positives on proper nouns/UK-US variants, support email-only 48h.
- Verdict: top manuscript editor for novelists/academics; overkill for email/Slack (Grammarly wins there); lifetime is the standout value in writing tools.
6. Best For / Not For
Best For Not For Novelists / self-pub authors editing in Scrivener (pacing/dialogue/echo reports) Everyday email/Slack/IM users wanting 1-click inline fix (→ Grammarly) Academics/students wanting deep style + separate plagiarism pack Non-English writers (English only, vs LanguageTool 30+ langs) Long-form bloggers/content writers (5k+ drafts) Casual short-text users — Free 500-word cap + report overload People who want to learn craft, not just de-error Teams needing real-time collaborative editing (individual-first) Buyers ok with $399 lifetime to escape subscription Mobile-first writers (no app, lags Grammarly mobile) 7. Competitors (Lane Map)
Lane Tool PWA edge / gap Mainstream grammar Grammarly (in your list) Grammarly faster/real-time/tone/mobile/non-EN; PWA deeper reports+Scrivener+lifetime Readability-only Hemingway Editor Hemingway one-time/minimal; PWA 25+ reports+integrations AI fiction draft Sudowrite Sudowrite drafts; PWA edits/reports (complements) Paraphrase+grammar QuillBot, Wordtune (Wordtune in your list) QuillBot/Wordtune paraphrase-first; PWA craft-reports-first Multilingual LanguageTool LanguageTool 30+ langs, simpler; PWA English depth AI writing suites Jasper, Writesonic, ChatGPT Those generate; PWA revises existing prose In-list overlap Wordtune (your list, Writing & Copywriting) Wordtune = rewrite/copy; PWA = manuscript editing coach